follow us:FacebookLinkedInTwitterRSS Feeds

advertisement

NJBIZ Lists

DataJoe b2b lead generation for purchase
Login to NJBIZ Lists
PRODUCTS SEARCH PROFILE ADD DATA CONTACT SUBSCRIBE
Shopping Cart (0 items)

HTML View

Need a map?
An interactive map of this list is available.

View map

Prefer PDFs?
A printer-friendly PDF of this list is available.

Download PDF file

Prefer Excel?
A complete spreadsheet of this list is available.

Download Excel file
NEW JERSEY'S TOP
Property and Casualty Insurers
Ranked by New Jersey direct premiums in 2011
By Danielle Mack
Rank | Prev. FIRM
YEAR ESTABLISHED
ADDRESS
PHONE | FAX | WEBSITE
SENIOR EXECUTIVE(S)N.J. Direct Premiums in 2011
1 | 1
New Jersey Manufacturers Insurance Co.
1913
301 Sullivan Way
P.O. Box 428
West Trenton, 08628-0227
(609) 883-1300 | (609) 882-3457 | www.njm.com
Bernard M. Flynn
$1,351,143,000
2 | 3
Progressive Garden State Insurance Co.
1937
CT Corporation System, 820 Bear Tavern Road, Suite 305
West Trenton, 08628
(440) 461-5000 | NA | www.progressive.com
Glenn M. Renwick
$258,210,000
3 | 5
Drive New Jersey Insurance Co.
1937
CT Corporation System, 820 Bear Tavern Road, Suite 305
West Trenton, 08628
(440) 461-5000 | NA | www.progressiveagent.com
Glenn M. Renwick
$209,468,000
4 | 4
Selective Insurance Group
1926
40 Wantage Ave.
Branchville, 07890
(973) 948-3000 | (973) 948-0282 | www.selective.com
Gregory E. Murphy
$193,623,000
5 | 2
Palisades Safety and Insurance Management Corp.
1992
331 Newman Springs Road, Suite 304
Red Bank, 07701
(908) 790-7800 | (732) 978-6172 | www.plymouthrocknj.com
Gerald Wilson
$184,960,000
6 | 6
High Point Property and Casualty Insurance Co.
2003
331 Newman Springs Road, Suite 304
Red Bank, 07701
(732) 978-6000 | (732) 978-6172 | www.plymouthrocknj.com
Gerald Wilson
$175,038,000
7 | 7
High Point Safety and Insurance Management Co.
2003
331 Newman Springs Road, Suite 304
Red Bank, 07701
(732) 978-6000 | (732) 978-6172 | www.plymouthrocknj.com
Gerald Wilson
$172,899,000
8 | 9
Selective Way Insurance Co.
1926
40 Wantage Ave.
Branchville, 07890
(973) 948-3000 | (973) 948-0282 | www.selectiveinsurance.com
Gregory E. Murphy
$154,765,000
9 | 8
Princeton Insurance
1976
746 Alexander Road
P.O. Box 5322
Princeton, 08540
(609) 452-9404 | (609) 734-8461 | www.princetoninsurance.com
Charles W. Lefevre
$147,924,000
10 | 10
Harleysville Insurance Co. of New Jersey
1917
112 W. Park Drive
Mount Laurel, 08054
(856) 642-9779 | (856) 642-9412 | www.harleysvillegroup.com
John J. Iannello
$124,200,000
11 | 11
High Point Preferred Insurance Co.
2003
331 Newman Springs Road, Suite 304
Red Bank, 07701
(732) 978-6000 | (732) 978-6172 | www.plymouthrocknj.com
Gerald Wilson
$122,922,000
12 | 13
The Chubb Corp.
1882
15 Mountain View Road
P.O. Box 1615
Warren, 07059-6711
(908) 903-2000 | (908) 903-7910 | www.chubb.com
John D. Finnegan, Richard G. Spiro, Paul J. Krump, Harold L. Morrison, Dino E. Robusto
$99,168,000
13 | 12
AAA Mid-Atlantic Insurance Co. of New Jersey
1927
2A S. Gold Drive
Hamilton, 08691
(609) 890-2220 | NA | www.aaamidatlantic.com
Paula Downey
$97,807,000
14 | 14
Selective Auto Insurance Co. of New Jersey
1926
40 Wantage Ave.
Branchville, 07890
(973) 948-3000 | (973) 948-0282 | www.selective.com
Gregory E. Murphy
$79,744,000
15 | 17
Cumberland Mutual Fire Insurance Co.
1844
633 Shiloh Pike
Bridgeton, 08302
(856) 451-4050 | (856) 451-7564 | www.cumberlandgroup.com
Paul J. Ritter III
$71,492,000
16 | 16
FMI Insurance Co.
1879
5 Broad St.
Branchville, 07826
(973) 948-3120 | (973) 948-7190 | www.fmiweb.com
James P. Ayers
$69,856,000
17 | 15
New Jersey Skylands Insurance Association(1)
NA
P.O. Box 50
Buffalo, NY 14240-0050
(866) 279-7688 | NA | www.njsi.com
Bruce Sanderson
$69,321,000
18 | 19
Franklin Mutual Insurance Co.
1879
5 Broad St.
P.O. Box 400
Branchville, 07826-0400
(973) 948-3120 | (973) 948-7190 | www.fmiweb.com
James P. Ayers
$61,100,000
19 | 24
New Jersey Casualty Insurance Co.
1913
301 Sullivan Way
P.O. Box 428
West Trenton, 08628
(609) 883-1300 | (609) 882-3457 | www.njm.com
Bernard M. Flynn
$59,572,000
20 | 18
MDAdvantage Insurance Co. of New Jersey
NA
2 Princess Road, Suite 2
Lawrenceville, 08648
(888) 355-5551 | (609) 896-0137 | www.mdadvantageonline.com
Patricia A. Costante
$57,479,000
21 | 20
New Jersey Re-Insurance Co.
1913
301 Sullivan Way
P.O. Box 428
West Trenton, 08628
(609) 883-1300 | (609) 882-3457 | www.njm.com
Bernard M. Flynn
$56,483,000
22 | 23
Mercer Insurance Co. of New Jersey
1844
P.O. Box 278
Pennington, 08534
(800) 223-0534 | (609) 737-8719 | www.unitedfiregroup.com
Randy A. Ramlo
$45,708,000
23 | 27
Citizens United Reciprocal Exchange
1990
214 Carnegie Center, Suite 101
Princeton, 08540
(609) 520-0800 | NA | www.cure.com
Lena Chang
$45,295,000
24 | 25
Continental Insurance Co. of New Jersey
1897
4 Century Drive
Parsippany, 07054
(973) 540-3600 | (973) 540-3602 | www.cna.com
Thomas F. Motamed
$43,620,000
25 | 22
21st Century Pinnacle Insurance Co.
NA
3 Beaver Valley Road
Wilmington, DE 19803
(302) 252-2000 | NA | www.21st.com
Tony DeSantis
$39,925,000
26 | 21
Palisades Insurance Co.
1992
Connell Corporate Park 200 Connell Drive, Suite 3000
Berkeley Heights, 07922
(908) 790-7800 | NA | www.palisades.com
Ed Fernandez
$39,739,000
27 | 26
IFA Insurance Co.
1972
14 Walnut Ave.
Clark, 07066
(732) 815-1201 | (732) 815-1778 | www.ifaauto.com
David Walsh
$38,394,000
28 | NR
Salem County Mutual Fire Insurance Co.
NA
91 Market St.
P.O. Box33
Salem, 08079
(856) 935-0939 | NA | NA
NA
$33,640,000
29 | 28
Teachers Auto Insurance Co.
NA
P.O. Box 903
Lincroft, 07738-0903
(866) 658-3224 | NA | www.nj-teachers.com
Marc V. Buro
$33,031,000
30 | 29
Farmers Insurance Co. of Flemington
1856
23 Royal Road
P.O. Box 148
Flemington, 08822
(908) 782-4120 | (908) 782-6899 | www.farmersofflemington.com
NA
$28,944,000
31 | 35
Founders Insurance Co.
NA
1645 E Birchwood Ave.
Des Plaines, IL 60018
(847) 768-0040 | (847) 795-0049 | www.foundersinsurance.com
NA
$24,755,000
32 | 32
Conventus International Insurance Exchange
NA
900 Route 9 North, Suite 503
Woodbridge, 07095
(877) 444-0484 | (732) 791-9431 | www.conventusnj.com
Richard Augustyn
$20,136,000
33 | 31
Rider Insurance Co.
NA
P.O. Box 3141
Union, 07083
(800) 595-6393 | (973) 258-9732 | www.ridewithrider.com
NA
$19,132,000
34 | 30
Palisades Property and Casualty Insurance Co.
1994
5006 Belmar Blvd.
Wall, 07727
(732) 378-4500 | (732) 665-1462 | www.palisades.com
Ed Fernandez
$18,523,000
35 | 42
New Jersey Indemnity Insurance Co.
1913
301 Sullivan Way
West Trenton, 08628
(800) 232-6600 | (609) 882-3457 | www.njm.com
Anthony G. Dickson
$17,839,000
36 | 38
Cumberland Insurance Co. Inc.
NA
633 Shiloh Pike
Bridgeton, 08302
(800) 232-6992 | (856) 451-7564 | www.cumberlandgroup.com
Robert P. Brady
$15,772,000
37 | 36
Firemans Fund Indemnity Corp.
NA
820 Bear Tavern Road
West Trenton, 08628
NA
NA
$14,761,000
38 | 39
New Jersey Physicians United Reciprocal Exchange
NA
214 Carnegie Center, Suite 101
Princeton, 08540
(877) 265-7873 | (609) 520-0225 | www.njpure.com
NA
$13,268,000
39 | 40
Preserver Insurance Co.
NA
95 Route 17 S.
P.O. Box 931
Paramus, 07653-0931
(800) 242-0332 | (201) 845-5186 | www.preserver.com
Patrick Haveron
$12,999,000
40 | 33
Camden Fire Insurance Association(2)
NA
P.O. Box 50
Buffalo, NY 14240-0050
(866) 992-4368 | NA | www.njsi.com
Thom McDaniel
$10,221,000
41 | 37
Progressive Freedom Insurance Co.
NA
485 Route 1 S., Building A, Suite 470
Iselin, 08830
(732) 726-5624 | NA | www.progressive.com
NA
$9,651,000
42 | 43
Fidelity Mohawk Insurance Co.
1879
5 Broad St.
Branchville, 07826
(973) 948-3120 | (973)948-7190 | www.fmiweb.com
NA
$8,570,000
43 | 44
International Fidelity Insurance Co.
1904
1 Newark Center, 20th Floor
Newark, 07102
(800) 333-4167 | (973) 624-1348 | www.ific.com
Francis L. Mitterhoff
$8,532,000
44 | 45
Rutgers Casualty Insurance Co.
1981
2250 Chapel Ave. W., Suite 200
Cherry Hill, 08002
(800) 222-3058 | (856) 779-0719 | www.rutgersinsurance.com
Nachum Stein
$8,475,000
45 | 47
American Millennium Insurance Co.
NA
5 Marine View Plaza Suite 201
Hoboken, 07030
(201) 714-9595 | (201) 714-9661 | www.aminsure.com
Martin (Marty) Beitler
$5,901,000
46 | 46
North River Insurance Co.
NA
c/o Crum & Forster 305 Madison Ave
Morristown, 07960
(973) 490-6600 | (877) 622-6206 | www.cfins.com
NA
$5,258,000
47 | 41
Twin Lights Insurance Co.
NA
331 Newman Springs Road Building Three
Red Bank, 07001
(908) 219-5050 | NA | www.twinlightsins.com
NA
$5,175,000
48 | 48
First Industry of American Insurance Co.
NA
119 Littleton Road
Parsippany, 07054
(973) 402-1200 | (973) 402-0770 | www.fiagroup.com
Patrick Lynch
$4,986,000
49 | 51
Crum & Forster Insurance Co.
NA
305 Madison Ave.
P.O. Box 1973
Morristown, 07962
(973) 490-6600 | NA | www.cfins.com
NA
$2,372,000
50 | 49
Garden State Indemnity Co. Inc.
NA
78 Court St.
Freehold, 07728
(732) 308-3464 | NA | NA
George J. Dittmar Jr.
$2,144,000
51 | 54
Bondex Insurance Co.
NA
Westminster Corporate Center 30A Vreeland Road, Suite 120
P.O. Box 6
Florham Park, 07932
(973) 437-9647 | NA | www.bondexins.com
NA
$1,284,000
52 | 55
Service Insurance Co.
NA
80 Main St.
West Orange, 07052
(973) 731-7650 | (973) 731-7889 | www.serviceinsuranceco.com
James S. Burger
$1,237,000
53 | 52
Kodiak Insurance Co.
NA
c/o Corporate Trust Co., 820 Bear Tavern Road
Trenton, 08628-1021
NA
NA
$444,000
54 | 56
First Founders Assurance Co.
NA
6 Mill Ridge Lane
Chester, 07930
(908) 879-0990 | NA | NA
NA
$395,000
55 | 53
Atlantic Employers Insurance Co.
NA
55 Haddonfield Road, Suite 210
Cherry Hill, 08002
(215) 640-1000 | NA | NA
NA
$159,000
56 | 58
ARI Casualty Co.
1948
9000 Midlantic Drive
Mount Laurel, 08054
(856) 778-1500 | (609) 436-0811 | www.arifleet.com
NA
$11,000
57 | NR
American European Insurance Group Inc.
NA
2250 West Chapel Ave., Suite 200
Cherry Hill, 08002-2094
(856) 779-0600 | (856) 779-0719 | www.aeiginsurance.com
NA
$0
57 | 57
Atradius Trade Credit Insurance Co. New Jersey
NA
5026 Campbell Blvd., Suite C
Baltimore, MD NA
(410) 246-5510 | NA | NA
NA
$0
57 | NR
Clarendon America Insurance Co.
NA
466 Lexington Ave., Suite 1900
New York, NY 10017
(212) 790-9700 | NA | NA
NA
$0
57 | NR
Clarendon National Insurance Co.
NA
466 Lexington Ave., 19th Floor
New York, NY 10017
(212) 790-9700 | (212) 790-9801 | www.clarendon.biz
Patrick Fee
$0
57 | NR
Mapfre Ins Co
NA
NA, FL NA
NA | NA | www.mapfrefl.com
NA
$0
57 | NR
New Jersey Skylands
2002
P.O. Box 622
Basking Ridge, 07920
(908) 766-8600 | NA | www.njsi.com
Alex Archimedes
$0
63 | 50
First Jersey Casualty Insurance Co. Inc.
NA
1333 Broad St.
Clifton, 07013
NA
NA
($24,000)
Back to Top