NJBIZ Lists

DataJoe email mailing lists from business publishers

PRODUCTS SEARCH PROFILE ADD DATA CONTACT SUBSCRIBE

HTML View


Need a map? An interactive map of this list is available.
View map


Prefer PDFs? A printer-friendly PDF of this list is available.
Download PDF file


Prefer Excel? A complete spreadsheet of this list is available.
Download Excel file

NEW JERSEY'S TOP

Property and Casualty Insurers

For full list, visit www.njbiz.com/lists

Ranked by New Jersey direct premiums in 2011

By Danielle Mack

Rank \| Prev.	FIRM YEAR ESTABLISHED	ADDRESS PHONE \| FAX \| WEBSITE	SENIOR EXECUTIVE(S)	N.J. Direct Premiums in 2011
1 \| 1	New Jersey Manufacturers Insurance Co. 1913	301 Sullivan Way P.O. Box 428 West Trenton, 08628-0227 (609) 883-1300 \| (609) 882-3457 \| www.njm.com	Bernard M. Flynn	$1,351,143,000
2 \| 3	Progressive Garden State Insurance Co. 1937	CT Corporation System, 820 Bear Tavern Road, Suite 305 West Trenton, 08628 (440) 461-5000 \| NA \| www.progressive.com	Glenn M. Renwick	$258,210,000
3 \| 5	Drive New Jersey Insurance Co. 1937	CT Corporation System, 820 Bear Tavern Road, Suite 305 West Trenton, 08628 (440) 461-5000 \| NA \| www.progressiveagent.com	Glenn M. Renwick	$209,468,000
4 \| 4	Selective Insurance Group 1926	40 Wantage Ave. Branchville, 07890 (973) 948-3000 \| (973) 948-0282 \| www.selective.com	Gregory E. Murphy	$193,623,000
5 \| 2	Palisades Safety and Insurance Management Corp. 1992	331 Newman Springs Road, Suite 304 Red Bank, 07701 (908) 790-7800 \| (732) 978-6172 \| www.plymouthrocknj.com	Gerald Wilson	$184,960,000
6 \| 6	High Point Property and Casualty Insurance Co. 2003	331 Newman Springs Road, Suite 304 Red Bank, 07701 (732) 978-6000 \| (732) 978-6172 \| www.plymouthrocknj.com	Gerald Wilson	$175,038,000
7 \| 7	High Point Safety and Insurance Management Co. 2003	331 Newman Springs Road, Suite 304 Red Bank, 07701 (732) 978-6000 \| (732) 978-6172 \| www.plymouthrocknj.com	Gerald Wilson	$172,899,000
8 \| 9	Selective Way Insurance Co. 1926	40 Wantage Ave. Branchville, 07890 (973) 948-3000 \| (973) 948-0282 \| www.selectiveinsurance.com	Gregory E. Murphy	$154,765,000
9 \| 8	Princeton Insurance 1976	746 Alexander Road P.O. Box 5322 Princeton, 08540 (609) 452-9404 \| (609) 734-8461 \| www.princetoninsurance.com	Charles W. Lefevre	$147,924,000
10 \| 10	Harleysville Insurance Co. of New Jersey 1917	112 W. Park Drive Mount Laurel, 08054 (856) 642-9779 \| (856) 642-9412 \| www.harleysvillegroup.com	John J. Iannello	$124,200,000
11 \| 11	High Point Preferred Insurance Co. 2003	331 Newman Springs Road, Suite 304 Red Bank, 07701 (732) 978-6000 \| (732) 978-6172 \| www.plymouthrocknj.com	Gerald Wilson	$122,922,000
12 \| 13	The Chubb Corp. 1882	15 Mountain View Road P.O. Box 1615 Warren, 07059-6711 (908) 903-2000 \| (908) 903-7910 \| www.chubb.com	John D. Finnegan, Richard G. Spiro, Paul J. Krump, Harold L. Morrison, Dino E. Robusto	$99,168,000
13 \| 12	AAA Mid-Atlantic Insurance Co. of New Jersey 1927	2A S. Gold Drive Hamilton, 08691 (609) 890-2220 \| NA \| www.aaamidatlantic.com	Paula Downey	$97,807,000
14 \| 14	Selective Auto Insurance Co. of New Jersey 1926	40 Wantage Ave. Branchville, 07890 (973) 948-3000 \| (973) 948-0282 \| www.selective.com	Gregory E. Murphy	$79,744,000
15 \| 17	Cumberland Mutual Fire Insurance Co. 1844	633 Shiloh Pike Bridgeton, 08302 (856) 451-4050 \| (856) 451-7564 \| www.cumberlandgroup.com	Paul J. Ritter III	$71,492,000
16 \| 16	FMI Insurance Co. 1879	5 Broad St. Branchville, 07826 (973) 948-3120 \| (973) 948-7190 \| www.fmiweb.com	James P. Ayers	$69,856,000
17 \| 15	New Jersey Skylands Insurance Association(1) NA	P.O. Box 50 Buffalo, NY 14240-0050 (866) 279-7688 \| NA \| www.njsi.com	Bruce Sanderson	$69,321,000
18 \| 19	Franklin Mutual Insurance Co. 1879	5 Broad St. P.O. Box 400 Branchville, 07826-0400 (973) 948-3120 \| (973) 948-7190 \| www.fmiweb.com	James P. Ayers	$61,100,000
19 \| 24	New Jersey Casualty Insurance Co. 1913	301 Sullivan Way P.O. Box 428 West Trenton, 08628 (609) 883-1300 \| (609) 882-3457 \| www.njm.com	Bernard M. Flynn	$59,572,000
20 \| 18	MDAdvantage Insurance Co. of New Jersey NA	2 Princess Road, Suite 2 Lawrenceville, 08648 (888) 355-5551 \| (609) 896-0137 \| www.mdadvantageonline.com	Patricia A. Costante	$57,479,000
21 \| 20	New Jersey Re-Insurance Co. 1913	301 Sullivan Way P.O. Box 428 West Trenton, 08628 (609) 883-1300 \| (609) 882-3457 \| www.njm.com	Bernard M. Flynn	$56,483,000
22 \| 23	Mercer Insurance Co. of New Jersey 1844	P.O. Box 278 Pennington, 08534 (800) 223-0534 \| (609) 737-8719 \| www.unitedfiregroup.com	Randy A. Ramlo	$45,708,000
23 \| 27	Citizens United Reciprocal Exchange 1990	214 Carnegie Center, Suite 101 Princeton, 08540 (609) 520-0800 \| NA \| www.cure.com	Lena Chang	$45,295,000
24 \| 25	Continental Insurance Co. of New Jersey 1897	4 Century Drive Parsippany, 07054 (973) 540-3600 \| (973) 540-3602 \| www.cna.com	Thomas F. Motamed	$43,620,000
25 \| 22	21st Century Pinnacle Insurance Co. NA	3 Beaver Valley Road Wilmington, DE 19803 (302) 252-2000 \| NA \| www.21st.com	Tony DeSantis	$39,925,000
26 \| 21	Palisades Insurance Co. 1992	Connell Corporate Park 200 Connell Drive, Suite 3000 Berkeley Heights, 07922 (908) 790-7800 \| NA \| www.palisades.com	Ed Fernandez	$39,739,000
27 \| 26	IFA Insurance Co. 1972	14 Walnut Ave. Clark, 07066 (732) 815-1201 \| (732) 815-1778 \| www.ifaauto.com	David Walsh	$38,394,000
28 \| NR	Salem County Mutual Fire Insurance Co. NA	91 Market St. P.O. Box33 Salem, 08079 (856) 935-0939 \| NA \| NA	NA	$33,640,000
29 \| 28	Teachers Auto Insurance Co. NA	P.O. Box 903 Lincroft, 07738-0903 (866) 658-3224 \| NA \| www.nj-teachers.com	Marc V. Buro	$33,031,000
30 \| 29	Farmers Insurance Co. of Flemington 1856	23 Royal Road P.O. Box 148 Flemington, 08822 (908) 782-4120 \| (908) 782-6899 \| www.farmersofflemington.com	NA	$28,944,000
31 \| 35	Founders Insurance Co. NA	1645 E Birchwood Ave. Des Plaines, IL 60018 (847) 768-0040 \| (847) 795-0049 \| www.foundersinsurance.com	NA	$24,755,000
32 \| 34	ARI Mutual Insurance Co. 1879	133 Franklin Corner Road, Suite 1 Lawrenceville, 08648-2531 (609) 882-7500 \| (609) 882-7790 \| www.ari-ins.com	Karen Fulton	$20,250,000
33 \| 32	Conventus International Insurance Exchange NA	900 Route 9 North, Suite 503 Woodbridge, 07095 (877) 444-0484 \| (732) 791-9431 \| www.conventusnj.com	Richard Augustyn	$20,136,000
34 \| 31	Rider Insurance Co. NA	P.O. Box 3141 Union, 07083 (800) 595-6393 \| (973) 258-9732 \| www.ridewithrider.com	NA	$19,132,000
35 \| 30	Palisades Property and Casualty Insurance Co. 1994	5006 Belmar Blvd. Wall, 07727 (732) 378-4500 \| (732) 665-1462 \| www.palisades.com	Ed Fernandez	$18,523,000
36 \| 42	New Jersey Indemnity Insurance Co. 1913	301 Sullivan Way West Trenton, 08628 (800) 232-6600 \| (609) 882-3457 \| www.njm.com	Anthony G. Dickson	$17,839,000
37 \| 38	Cumberland Insurance Co. Inc. NA	633 Shiloh Pike Bridgeton, 08302 (800) 232-6992 \| (856) 451-7564 \| www.cumberlandgroup.com	Robert P. Brady	$15,772,000
38 \| 36	Firemans Fund Indemnity Corp. NA	820 Bear Tavern Road West Trenton, 08628 NA	NA	$14,761,000
39 \| 39	New Jersey Physicians United Reciprocal Exchange NA	214 Carnegie Center, Suite 101 Princeton, 08540 (877) 265-7873 \| (609) 520-0225 \| www.njpure.com	NA	$13,268,000
40 \| 40	Preserver Insurance Co. NA	95 Route 17 S. P.O. Box 931 Paramus, 07653-0931 (800) 242-0332 \| (201) 845-5186 \| www.preserver.com	Patrick Haveron	$12,999,000
41 \| 33	Camden Fire Insurance Association(2) NA	P.O. Box 50 Buffalo, NY 14240-0050 (866) 992-4368 \| NA \| www.njsi.com	Thom McDaniel	$10,221,000
42 \| 37	Progressive Freedom Insurance Co. NA	485 Route 1 S., Building A, Suite 470 Iselin, 08830 (732) 726-5624 \| NA \| www.progressive.com	NA	$9,651,000
43 \| 43	Fidelity Mohawk Insurance Co. 1879	5 Broad St. Branchville, 07826 (973) 948-3120 \| (973)948-7190 \| www.fmiweb.com	NA	$8,570,000
44 \| 44	International Fidelity Insurance Co. 1904	1 Newark Center, 20th Floor Newark, 07102 (800) 333-4167 \| (973) 624-1348 \| www.ific.com	Francis L. Mitterhoff	$8,532,000
45 \| 45	Rutgers Casualty Insurance Co. 1981	2250 Chapel Ave. W., Suite 200 Cherry Hill, 08002 (800) 222-3058 \| (856) 779-0719 \| www.rutgersinsurance.com	Nachum Stein	$8,475,000
46 \| 47	American Millennium Insurance Co. NA	5 Marine View Plaza Suite 201 Hoboken, 07030 (201) 714-9595 \| (201) 714-9661 \| www.aminsure.com	Martin (Marty) Beitler	$5,901,000
47 \| 46	North River Insurance Co. NA	c/o Crum & Forster 305 Madison Ave Morristown, 07960 (973) 490-6600 \| (877) 622-6206 \| www.cfins.com	NA	$5,258,000
48 \| 41	Twin Lights Insurance Co. NA	331 Newman Springs Road Building Three Red Bank, 07001 (908) 219-5050 \| NA \| www.twinlightsins.com	NA	$5,175,000
49 \| 48	First Industry of American Insurance Co. NA	119 Littleton Road Parsippany, 07054 (973) 402-1200 \| (973) 402-0770 \| www.fiagroup.com	Patrick Lynch	$4,986,000
50 \| 51	Crum & Forster Insurance Co. NA	305 Madison Ave. P.O. Box 1973 Morristown, 07962 (973) 490-6600 \| NA \| www.cfins.com	NA	$2,372,000
51 \| 49	Garden State Indemnity Co. Inc. NA	78 Court St. Freehold, 07728 (732) 308-3464 \| NA \| NA	George J. Dittmar Jr.	$2,144,000
52 \| 54	Bondex Insurance Co. NA	Westminster Corporate Center 30A Vreeland Road, Suite 120 P.O. Box 6 Florham Park, 07932 (973) 437-9647 \| NA \| www.bondexins.com	NA	$1,284,000
53 \| 55	Service Insurance Co. NA	80 Main St. West Orange, 07052 (973) 731-7650 \| (973) 731-7889 \| www.serviceinsuranceco.com	James S. Burger	$1,237,000
54 \| 52	Kodiak Insurance Co. NA	c/o Corporate Trust Co., 820 Bear Tavern Road Trenton, 08628-1021 NA	NA	$444,000
55 \| 56	First Founders Assurance Co. NA	6 Mill Ridge Lane Chester, 07930 (908) 879-0990 \| NA \| NA	NA	$395,000
56 \| 53	Atlantic Employers Insurance Co. NA	55 Haddonfield Road, Suite 210 Cherry Hill, 08002 (215) 640-1000 \| NA \| NA	NA	$159,000
57 \| 58	ARI Casualty Co. 1948	9000 Midlantic Drive Mount Laurel, 08054 (856) 778-1500 \| (609) 436-0811 \| www.arifleet.com	NA	$11,000
58 \| NR	American European Insurance Group Inc. NA	2250 West Chapel Ave., Suite 200 Cherry Hill, 08002-2094 (856) 779-0600 \| (856) 779-0719 \| www.aeiginsurance.com	NA	$0
58 \| 57	Atradius Trade Credit Insurance Co. New Jersey NA	5026 Campbell Blvd., Suite C Baltimore, Md. NA (410) 246-5510 \| NA \| NA	NA	$0
58 \| NR	Clarendon America Insurance Co. NA	466 Lexington Ave., Suite 1900 New York, NY 10017 (212) 790-9700 \| NA \| NA	NA	$0
58 \| NR	Clarendon National Insurance Co. NA	466 Lexington Ave., 19th Floor New York, NY 10017 (212) 790-9700 \| (212) 790-9801 \| www.clarendon.biz	Patrick Fee	$0
58 \| NR	Mapfre Ins Co NA	NA, FL NA NA \| NA \| www.mapfrefl.com	NA	$0
58 \| NR	New Jersey Skylands 2002	P.O. Box 622 Basking Ridge, 07920 (908) 766-8600 \| NA \| www.njsi.com	Alex Archimedes	$0
64 \| 50	First Jersey Casualty Insurance Co. Inc. NA	1333 Broad St. Clifton, 07013 NA	NA	($24,000)

Source: New Jersey Department of Banking and Insurance. List includes domestic companies as defined by the state. (1) Subsidiary of New Jersey Skylands Management LLC. (2) Subsidiary of New Jersey Skylands. NA: Not Available. NR: Not Ranked. There is no charge to be included in NJBIZ lists. We assume that information provided by representatives is accurate and truthful. We are not responsible for the omission of organizations that do not respond to our questionnaire or to fax or phone requests for information. If your organization was omitted and you wish it to be included in future lists, please go to our website at www.njbiz.com and select "Lists" then "Add Data." You may also contact lists@njbiz.com or at (732) 246-5733. Information may also be faxed to (732) 846-0421. Information received after press deadline cannot be included. The lists, or any parts of them, cannot be reproduced without written permission from NJBIZ. For more on Information Products from NJBIZ, please call (732) 246-5701.