Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Google Plus RSS

NJBIZ Lists

DataJoe b2b lead generation for sale
Login to NJBIZ Lists
PRODUCTS SEARCH PROFILE ADD DATA CONTACT SUBSCRIBE
Shopping Cart (0 items)

HTML View

Need a map?
An interactive map of this list is available.

View map

Prefer PDFs?
A printer-friendly PDF of this list is available.

Download PDF file

Prefer Excel?
A complete spreadsheet of this list is available.

Download Excel file
NEW JERSEY'S TOP
Property and Casualty Insurers
Ranked by New Jersey direct premiums in 2011
By Danielle Mack
Rank | Prev. FIRM
YEAR ESTABLISHED
ADDRESS
PHONE | FAX | WEBSITE
SENIOR EXECUTIVE(S)N.J. Direct Premiums in 2011
1 | 1
New Jersey Manufacturers Insurance Co.
1913
301 Sullivan Way
P.O. Box 428
West Trenton, 08628-0227
(609) 883-1300 | (609) 882-3457 | www.njm.com
Bernard M. Flynn
$1,351,143,000
2 | 3
Progressive Garden State Insurance Co.
1937
CT Corporation System, 820 Bear Tavern Road, Suite 305
West Trenton, 08628
(440) 461-5000 | NA | www.progressive.com
Glenn M. Renwick
$258,210,000
3 | 5
Drive New Jersey Insurance Co.
1937
CT Corporation System, 820 Bear Tavern Road, Suite 305
West Trenton, 08628
(440) 461-5000 | NA | www.progressiveagent.com
Glenn M. Renwick
$209,468,000
4 | 4
Selective Insurance Group
1926
40 Wantage Ave.
Branchville, 07890
(973) 948-3000 | (973) 948-0282 | www.selective.com
Gregory E. Murphy
$193,623,000
5 | 2
Palisades Safety and Insurance Management Corp.
1992
331 Newman Springs Road, Suite 304
Red Bank, 07701
(908) 790-7800 | (732) 978-6172 | www.plymouthrocknj.com
Gerald Wilson
$184,960,000
6 | 6
High Point Property and Casualty Insurance Co.
2003
331 Newman Springs Road, Suite 304
Red Bank, 07701
(732) 978-6000 | (732) 978-6172 | www.plymouthrocknj.com
Gerald Wilson
$175,038,000
7 | 7
High Point Safety and Insurance Management Co.
2003
331 Newman Springs Road, Suite 304
Red Bank, 07701
(732) 978-6000 | (732) 978-6172 | www.plymouthrocknj.com
Gerald Wilson
$172,899,000
8 | 9
Selective Way Insurance Co.
1926
40 Wantage Ave.
Branchville, 07890
(973) 948-3000 | (973) 948-0282 | www.selectiveinsurance.com
Gregory E. Murphy
$154,765,000
9 | 8
Princeton Insurance
1976
746 Alexander Road
P.O. Box 5322
Princeton, 08540
(609) 452-9404 | (609) 734-8461 | www.princetoninsurance.com
Charles W. Lefevre
$147,924,000
10 | 10
Harleysville Insurance Co. of New Jersey
1917
112 W. Park Drive
Mount Laurel, 08054
(856) 642-9779 | (856) 642-9412 | www.harleysvillegroup.com
John J. Iannello
$124,200,000
11 | 11
High Point Preferred Insurance Co.
2003
331 Newman Springs Road, Suite 304
Red Bank, 07701
(732) 978-6000 | (732) 978-6172 | www.plymouthrocknj.com
Gerald Wilson
$122,922,000
12 | 13
The Chubb Corp.
1882
15 Mountain View Road
P.O. Box 1615
Warren, 07059-6711
(908) 903-2000 | (908) 903-7910 | www.chubb.com
John D. Finnegan, Richard G. Spiro, Paul J. Krump, Harold L. Morrison Jr., Dino E. Robusto
$99,168,000
13 | 12
AAA Mid-Atlantic Insurance Co. of New Jersey
1927
2A S. Gold Drive
Hamilton, 08691
(609) 890-2220 | NA | www.aaamidatlantic.com
Paula Downey
$97,807,000
14 | 14
Selective Auto Insurance Co. of New Jersey
1926
40 Wantage Ave.
Branchville, 07890
(973) 948-3000 | (973) 948-0282 | www.selective.com
Gregory E. Murphy
$79,744,000
15 | 17
Cumberland Mutual Fire Insurance Co.
1844
633 Shiloh Pike
Bridgeton, 08302
(856) 451-4050 | (856) 451-7564 | www.cumberlandgroup.com
Paul J. Ritter III
$71,492,000
16 | 16
FMI Insurance Co.
1879
5 Broad St.
Branchville, 07826
(973) 948-3120 | (973) 948-7190 | www.fmiweb.com
James P. Ayers
$69,856,000
17 | 15
New Jersey Skylands Insurance Association(1)
NA
P.O. Box 50
Buffalo, NY 14240-0050
(866) 279-7688 | NA | www.njsi.com
Bruce Sanderson
$69,321,000
18 | 19
Franklin Mutual Insurance Co.
1879
5 Broad St.
P.O. Box 400
Branchville, 07826-0400
(973) 948-3120 | (973) 948-7190 | www.fmiweb.com
James P. Ayers, Brian Lytwynec
$61,100,000
19 | 24
New Jersey Casualty Insurance Co.
1913
301 Sullivan Way
P.O. Box 428
West Trenton, 08628
(609) 883-1300 | (609) 882-3457 | www.njm.com
Bernard M. Flynn
$59,572,000
20 | 18
MDAdvantage Insurance Co. of New Jersey
NA
2 Princess Road, Suite 2
Lawrenceville, 08648
(888) 355-5551 | (609) 896-0137 | www.mdadvantageonline.com
Patricia A. Costante
$57,479,000
21 | 20
New Jersey Re-Insurance Co.
1913
301 Sullivan Way
P.O. Box 428
West Trenton, 08628
(609) 883-1300 | (609) 882-3457 | www.njm.com
Bernard M. Flynn
$56,483,000
22 | 23
Mercer Insurance Co. of New Jersey
1844
P.O. Box 278
Pennington, 08534
(800) 223-0534 | (609) 737-8719 | www.unitedfiregroup.com
Randy A. Ramlo
$45,708,000
23 | 27
Citizens United Reciprocal Exchange
1990
214 Carnegie Center, Suite 101
Princeton, 08540
(609) 520-0800 | NA | www.cure.com
Lena Chang
$45,295,000
24 | 25
Continental Insurance Co. of New Jersey
1897
4 Century Drive
Parsippany, 07054
(973) 540-3600 | (973) 540-3602 | www.cna.com
Thomas F. Motamed
$43,620,000
25 | 22
21st Century Pinnacle Insurance Co.
NA
3 Beaver Valley Road
Wilmington, DE 19803
(302) 252-2000 | NA | www.21st.com
Tony DeSantis
$39,925,000
26 | 21
Palisades Insurance Co.
1992
Connell Corporate Park 200 Connell Drive, Suite 3000
Berkeley Heights, 07922
(908) 790-7800 | NA | www.palisades.com
Ed Fernandez
$39,739,000
27 | 26
IFA Insurance Co.
1972
14 Walnut Ave.
Clark, 07066
(732) 815-1201 | (732) 815-1778 | www.ifaauto.com
David Walsh
$38,394,000
28 | NR
Salem County Mutual Fire Insurance Co.
NA
91 Market St.
P.O. Box33
Salem, 08079
(856) 935-0939 | NA | NA
NA
$33,640,000
29 | 28
Teachers Auto Insurance Co.
NA
P.O. Box 903
Lincroft, 07738-0903
(866) 658-3224 | NA | www.nj-teachers.com
Marc V. Buro
$33,031,000
30 | 29
Farmers Insurance Co. of Flemington
1856
23 Royal Road
P.O. Box 148
Flemington, 08822
(908) 782-4120 | (908) 782-6899 | www.farmersofflemington.com
NA
$28,944,000
31 | 35
Founders Insurance Co.
NA
1645 E Birchwood Ave.
Des Plaines, IL 60018
(847) 768-0040 | (847) 795-0049 | www.foundersinsurance.com
NA
$24,755,000
32 | 32
Conventus International Insurance Exchange
NA
900 Route 9 North, Suite 503
Woodbridge, 07095
(877) 444-0484 | (732) 791-9431 | www.conventusnj.com
Richard Augustyn
$20,136,000
33 | 31
Rider Insurance Co.
NA
P.O. Box 3141
Union, 07083
(800) 595-6393 | (973) 258-9732 | www.ridewithrider.com
NA
$19,132,000
34 | 30
Palisades Property and Casualty Insurance Co.
1994
5006 Belmar Blvd.
Wall, 07727
(732) 378-4500 | (732) 665-1462 | www.palisades.com
Ed Fernandez
$18,523,000
35 | 42
New Jersey Indemnity Insurance Co.
1913
301 Sullivan Way
West Trenton, 08628
(800) 232-6600 | (609) 882-3457 | www.njm.com
Anthony G. Dickson
$17,839,000
36 | 38
Cumberland Insurance Co. Inc.
NA
633 Shiloh Pike
Bridgeton, 08302
(800) 232-6992 | (856) 451-7564 | www.cumberlandgroup.com
Robert P. Brady
$15,772,000
37 | 36
Firemans Fund Indemnity Corp.
NA
820 Bear Tavern Road
West Trenton, 08628
NA
NA
$14,761,000
38 | 39
New Jersey Physicians United Reciprocal Exchange
NA
214 Carnegie Center, Suite 101
Princeton, 08540
(877) 265-7873 | (609) 520-0225 | www.njpure.com
NA
$13,268,000
39 | 40
Preserver Insurance Co.
NA
95 Route 17 S.
P.O. Box 931
Paramus, 07653-0931
(800) 242-0332 | (201) 845-5186 | www.preserver.com
Patrick Haveron
$12,999,000
40 | 33
Camden Fire Insurance Association(2)
NA
P.O. Box 50
Buffalo, NY 14240-0050
(866) 992-4368 | NA | www.njsi.com
Thom McDaniel
$10,221,000
41 | 37
Progressive Freedom Insurance Co.
NA
485 Route 1 S., Building A, Suite 470
Iselin, 08830
(732) 726-5624 | NA | www.progressive.com
NA
$9,651,000
42 | 43
Fidelity Mohawk Insurance Co.
1879
5 Broad St.
Branchville, 07826
(973) 948-3120 | (973)948-7190 | www.fmiweb.com
NA
$8,570,000
43 | 44
International Fidelity Insurance Co.
1904
1 Newark Center, 20th Floor
Newark, 07102
(800) 333-4167 | (973) 624-1348 | www.ific.com
Francis L. Mitterhoff
$8,532,000
44 | 45
Rutgers Casualty Insurance Co.
1981
2250 Chapel Ave. W., Suite 200
Cherry Hill, 08002
(800) 222-3058 | (856) 779-0719 | www.rutgersinsurance.com
Nachum Stein
$8,475,000
45 | 47
American Millennium Insurance Co.
NA
5 Marine View Plaza Suite 201
Hoboken, 07030
(201) 714-9595 | (201) 714-9661 | www.aminsure.com
Martin (Marty) Beitler
$5,901,000
46 | 46
North River Insurance Co.
NA
c/o Crum & Forster 305 Madison Ave
Morristown, 07960
(973) 490-6600 | (877) 622-6206 | www.cfins.com
NA
$5,258,000
47 | 41
Twin Lights Insurance Co.
NA
331 Newman Springs Road Building Three
Red Bank, 07001
(908) 219-5050 | NA | www.twinlightsins.com
NA
$5,175,000
48 | 48
First Industry of American Insurance Co.
NA
119 Littleton Road
Parsippany, 07054
(973) 402-1200 | (973) 402-0770 | www.fiagroup.com
Patrick Lynch
$4,986,000
49 | 51
Crum & Forster Insurance Co.
NA
305 Madison Ave.
P.O. Box 1973
Morristown, 07962
(973) 490-6600 | NA | www.cfins.com
NA
$2,372,000
50 | 49
Garden State Indemnity Co. Inc.
NA
78 Court St.
Freehold, 07728
(732) 308-3464 | NA | NA
George J. Dittmar Jr.
$2,144,000
51 | 54
Bondex Insurance Co.
NA
Westminster Corporate Center 30A Vreeland Road, Suite 120
P.O. Box 6
Florham Park, 07932
(973) 437-9647 | NA | www.bondexins.com
NA
$1,284,000
52 | 55
Service Insurance Co.
NA
80 Main St.
West Orange, 07052
(973) 731-7650 | (973) 731-7889 | www.serviceinsuranceco.com
James S. Burger
$1,237,000
53 | 52
Kodiak Insurance Co.
NA
c/o Corporate Trust Co., 820 Bear Tavern Road
Trenton, 08628-1021
NA
NA
$444,000
54 | 56
First Founders Assurance Co.
NA
6 Mill Ridge Lane
Chester, 07930
(908) 879-0990 | NA | NA
NA
$395,000
55 | 53
Atlantic Employers Insurance Co.
NA
55 Haddonfield Road, Suite 210
Cherry Hill, 08002
(215) 640-1000 | NA | NA
NA
$159,000
56 | 58
ARI Casualty Co.
1948
9000 Midlantic Drive
Mount Laurel, 08054
(856) 778-1500 | (609) 436-0811 | www.arifleet.com
NA
$11,000
57 | NR
American European Insurance Group Inc.
NA
2250 West Chapel Ave., Suite 200
Cherry Hill, 08002-2094
(856) 779-0600 | (856) 779-0719 | www.aeiginsurance.com
NA
$0
57 | 57
Atradius Trade Credit Insurance Co. New Jersey
NA
5026 Campbell Blvd., Suite C
Baltimore, MD NA
(410) 246-5510 | NA | NA
NA
$0
57 | NR
Clarendon America Insurance Co.
NA
466 Lexington Ave., Suite 1900
New York, NY 10017
(212) 790-9700 | NA | NA
NA
$0
57 | NR
Clarendon National Insurance Co.
NA
466 Lexington Ave., 19th Floor
New York, NY 10017
(212) 790-9700 | (212) 790-9801 | www.clarendon.biz
Patrick Fee
$0
57 | NR
Mapfre Ins Co
NA
NA, FL NA
NA | NA | www.mapfrefl.com
NA
$0
57 | NR
New Jersey Skylands
2002
P.O. Box 622
Basking Ridge, 07920
(908) 766-8600 | NA | www.njsi.com
Alex Archimedes
$0
63 | 50
First Jersey Casualty Insurance Co. Inc.
NA
1333 Broad St.
Clifton, 07013
NA
NA
($24,000)

NJBIZ Poll Question of the Week

Should sports betting be allowed in New Jersey? Vote View Results