Health Republic Insurance just announced plans to withdraw from the Affordable Care Act marketplace in New Jersey next year. The insurer follows Oscar Health Insurance and UnitedHealthcare, also exiting the marketplace in 2017. Aetna, meanwhile, has scrapped plans to provide coverage here next year.
Are the exits a sign the ACA is failing? And what can we do to make sure a vibrant and competitive market remains in New Jersey?
First I think it’s important to remember what New Jersey had in place before the ACA. We were ahead in many ways, such as having laws that prevented insurers from discriminating based on a person’s health history and allowing unmarried dependents to stay on their parents’ health insurance until the age of 31.
Back in 2013, before the ACA marketplace started, we had only about 147,000 people covered through our individual market. Most people signed up for the “basic and essential plan,” which provided somewhat minimal benefits but protected members in the case of an emergency. We had six plans, though two companies had the lions’ share of the market. With no subsidies, premiums were high.
It was a market in a slow death spiral.
Yet once the ACA marketplace plans started in 2014, total enrollment for both the ACA marketplace and the state-run individual market (this is where people could buy plans without a subsidy directly from insurers)peaked this year at about 359,000 covered lives. The reason? The subsidies. Over 80 percent of those in the ACA marketplace in New Jersey receive a subsidy. The average subsidy in 2016 is $291 per month. Original estimates projected that about 570,000 people would gain coverage through the ACA marketplace and state-run individual market. So we are still below the goal by 210,000 lives.
Today we are learning that subsidies alone will not insure the vibrant and competitive marketplace we need. Having worked in the insurance industry, I have seen, first hand, how competition drives companies to work more cooperatively with health care providers. Competition drives insurers to be good corporate citizens responsive to both regulators and consumers. Competition pushes companies to find ways to reduce their administrative costs and keep premiums as low as possible while also delivering the service and health care choices their members want.
How can we keep healthy competition alive?
The problem is not unique to New Jersey and insurers are pulling out in other states as well. The Obama administration just announced some standards to strengthen the marketplace for 2018 that make sense. They are changing some of the risk adjustment strategies, extending the reinsurance program, and also planning intensive outreach to consumers who still haven’t signed up, especially younger people and Latinos.
Insurers leaving the market cite the rising costs of health care as well as the poorer than expected risk pool. No insurer can survive by insuring mostly high-risk people. We need more young and healthy people to join up. The federal government is seeking to increase enrollment by working with the Internal Revenue Service to contact people who paid a penalty for not having coverage. The government would reach out to these people with information about how to enroll.
We also need to explore other ways to maintain a healthy ACA marketplace. We need an on-going conversation with all stakeholders. Looking back at 2013 shows us that we cannot turn back the clock. For anyone in need of health insurance things today are so much better. The ACA is more than just the marketplace and includes significant changes such as the expansion of Medicaid.
We need to keep things moving forward.
What follows is a starting point of ideas in the forefront of this critical discussion. Some are controversial and I do not necessarily agree with each proposal here. But I believe the situation is concerning enough to put all ideas on the table.
Linda Schwimmer is CEO and president of the New Jersey Health Care Quality Institute. The Quality Institute is the only independent, nonpartisan, multistakeholder advocate for health care quality in New Jersey.